Autoship

New customer? Earn $10 when you place your first order over $39! New? Get $10 on your first $39+ order!

Save 15% on your 1st Autoship learn more

Earn up to 5% Rewards Back Today! learn more

Frequent Buyer? Earn a free bag Today! learn more

Get help from our pet experts

1-888-887-0063

Sign In Create Account
Pet Insurance Quote

Earn up to 5% Rewards back! Learn More
You have no items in your cart. Start shopping for your best furry friend today! Shop Now

Dehydrated Food
Dry Food
Freeze-Dried Food
Veterinary Diet
Wet Food

Biscuits & Crunchy
Bones, Bully & Chews
Dental Treats
Freeze-Dried Treats
Jerky Treats

Beds
Home & Gifts
Bowls & Feeders
Medical & Mobility
Cleaning & Waste
Ramps & Stairs
Crates, Gates & Pens
Training & Behavior
Grooming
Travel & Carriers

Anxiety & Calming
Dental Care
Flea & Tick
Hip & Joint Care
Vitamins/Supplements

Boots & Shoes
Costumes
Dresses
Hoodies
Shirts

Collars & Leashes All

Collar Charms
Collars
Harnesses
ID Tags
Leashes

Chew Toys
Fetch Toys
Interactive Toys
Plush Toys
Rope & Tug Toys

Canine Caviar

Carna4 dog food

Chips Natural treats

Food All

Dehydrated Food
Dry Food
Food Topper
Freeze-Dried Food
Wet Food
Veterinary Diet

Treats All

Catnip & Pet Grass
Crunchy Treats
Food Topper
Freeze-Dried & Dehydrated Treats
Lickable Treats
Soft & Chewy Treats

Anxiety & Calming
Digestive & Urinary Aid
Ear Care
Eye Care
First Aid & Recovery
Skin & Coat Care
Vitamins/Supplements

Toys All

Balls & Chasers
Catnip Toys
Interactive & Electronic Toys
Plush & Mice Toys
Scratchers
Teasers & Wands
Variety Packs

Accessories
Beds
Carriers
Cleaning & Waste
Clothes
Collar Charms
Collars & Leashes
Crates & Cages
Flea & Tick
Cat Furniture
Harnesses
Home & Gifts
Home Decor
Cat Litter
Scratching Posts
Travel

Jackson Galaxy pet store

Fancy Feast food

Fussie Cat food

Digestive Health
Heartworm
Pain Relief
Eye and Ear Care
Flea & Tick
Heart Health
Antibiotics
Allergy Relief
Skin Care

Veterinary Diet All

Farmina Veterinary Diet

Pharmacy by Pet

Pharmacy for Dogs
Pharmacy for Cats

Health Condition

Anxiety Relief
Brain Health
Digestive Health
Heart Care
Pain Relief
Skin & Coat Health

Popular Brands All

Cosequin
Kong
Senilife
Yumwoof!
Royal Canin
Greenies
Friskies
NexGard
Frontline
The Honest Kitchen
Fancy Feast
Honest Paws
Checkups
Zesty Paws

Coupons
Monthly Fetch Ad
Open Box Deals
Nutrition and Wellness Bargains

🎃 Halloween Shop

New Arrivals

Loyalty Program

MVP Rewards
Frequent Buyer Program

Save 15% on your 1st Autoship learn more

Shop
Shop For Dogs
Shop For Cats
Shop By Brand
🎃 Halloween Shop
New Arrivals
Deals
Loyalty Program
- MVP Rewards
- Frequent Buyer Program
Account
Sign In
Create Account
Help
Pet Insurance Quote

CATEGORY

Dog Costumes

Dog Healthcare

Dog Medical and Mobility

Dog Toys

Dog Training & Behavior

Dog Treats

Cat Treats

Brands

Canine Naturals

Chicken Soup for the Soul

Gaines Family Farmstead

Hank & Roy Pet Treats

Himalayan Dog Chews

Jones Natural Chews

K9 Granola Factory

Lord Jameson Organic Dog Treats

Marcy's Pet Kitchen

Old Mother Hubbard

Polka Dog Bakery

Portland Pet Food

Smart Cookie Barkery

The Honest Kitchen

The Lazy Dog Cookie Co

Tuesday's Natural Dog

Whitebridge Pet

Winnie Lou - The Canine Co.

K9 Granola Factory

The Honest Kitchen

Tuesday's Natural Dog

Whitebridge Pet

+ View All

Size

Breed Size

Extra Small & Toy Breeds

Featured Line

Advent Calendar

Bocces Advent Calendar

Earth Animal, Stella & Chewy, K9 Natural

Everydays Treats by Wonder Bark

Greenies Pill Pockets

Himalayan Deal Cheese Chews

Advent Calendar

Bocces Advent Calendar

Earth Animal, Stella & Chewy, K9 Natural

Everydays Treats by Wonder Bark

Greenies Pill Pockets

Himalayan Deal Cheese Chews

+ View All

Flavor

Beef Bone Broth

Black Solider Fly Larvae (Grubs)

+ View All

Frequent Buyer Program

Frequent Buyer Products

Gender

Health Feature

Appetite Stimulation

Dental & Breath Care

Digestive Health

Hip & Joint Support

Skin & Coat Health

Super Antioxidant

Thyroid Support

Urinary Tract Health

Vitamins & Minerals

Weight Management

Digestive Health

Hip & Joint Support

Skin & Coat Health

Super Antioxidant

Vitamins & Minerals

+ View All

Holiday & Special Occasions

+ View All

Ingredients

Apple Cider Vinegar

Beef Bone Broth

Black Solider Fly Larvae (Grubs)

Buckwheat Flour

Citric Acid (preservative)

Coconut Glycerin

Egg Shell Membrane

Green Tea Extract

Mixed Tocopherols

No Artificial Flavors

Rosemary Extract

Vegetable Glycerin

Vitamin Complex

No Artificial Flavors

+ View All

Lifestage

Patterns

Pet

Seasons

Shop Sustainable

Special Diet

Limited Ingredient Diet

Sensitive Digestion

Limited Ingredient Diet

+ View All

Treat Type

Home
(145 items)

Peanut Butter

Sort By:

101 - 200 of 145 Items

Spunky Pup Holiday Dog Treats - 25 Day Advent Calendar

Starting at:
$12.99

Save 25% at checkout on select sizes

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Spunky Pup Holiday Dog Treats - Giggle Tree in Peanut Butter

Starting at:

$7.99

$7.59 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Spunky Pup Holiday Dog Treats - 11 Assorted Spunky Cookies Tray

Starting at:
$17.99

Save 25% at checkout on select sizes

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Portland Pet Food Brew Biscuit Dog Treats - Beef Broth

Starting at:

$9.99

$9.49 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Portland Pet Food Brew Biscuit Dog Treats - Pumpkin

Starting at:
$9.99

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Earthly Pill Buddy Naturals Dog Pill Pockets- Peanut Butter & Honey

Starting at:

$12.99

$12.34 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Earthly Pill Buddy Naturals Dog Pill Pockets- Peanut Butter & Banana

Starting at:

$12.99

$12.34 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Earthly Pill Buddy Naturals Dog Pill Pockets - Peanut Butter & Apple

Starting at:

$12.99

$12.34 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Spunky Pup Folds of Honor Dog Treats - Peanut Butter Patriot Paws

Starting at:
$9.99

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Spunky Pup Folds of Honor Dog Treats - Red, White & Blue Paws

Starting at:
$9.99

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Hank & Roy Natural Dog Treats - Peanut Butter Stuffed Bones

Starting at:

$4.99

$4.74 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
This product is currently rated
This product was rated by customers from 1-5 stars. 5 is best.

5.0 (4)

Zuke's Mini Naturals Dog Treats - Peanut Butter

Starting at:

$7.99

$7.59 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer

This product is currently rated
This product was rated by customers from 1-5 stars. 5 is best.

5.0 (2)

Buddy Biscuits Crunchy Dog Treats - Peanut Butter

Starting at:

$7.99

$7.59 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer

This product is currently rated
This product was rated by customers from 1-5 stars. 5 is best.

5.0 (1)

Barkworthies Stuffed Beef Shin Bone Dog Treat - Peanut Butter Blend

Starting at:
$6.99

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer

This product is currently rated
This product was rated by customers from 1-5 stars. 5 is best.

5.0 (1)

Cloud Star Wag More Bark Less Oats & Grains Biscuits with Crunchy Peanut Butter Dog Treats

Starting at:

$8.49

$8.07 With Autoship

Save 25% at checkout on select sizes

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
VetriScience Pill Hiders Dog Treat - Peanut Butter Flavored

Starting at:

$10.97

$10.42 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer

Barkworthies I Can't Believe It's Not Rawhide Rolls Dog Treat - Peanut Butter

Starting at:

$15.99

$15.19 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Pawstruck Filled Bone Dog Treat - Peanut Butter

Starting at:

$24.28

$23.07 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer

Marcy's Pet Kitchen All-Natural Gluten-Free Baked Dog Treats - Peanut Butter

Starting at:

$15.49

$14.72 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer

CollaChews Peanut Butter & Collagen Rolls Dog Treat

Starting at:

$14.99

$14.24 With Autoship

Save 25% at checkout on select sizes

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Sold Out

KONG Stuff N' Easy Treat Dog Treat - Peanut Butter

Starting at:

$9.99

$9.49 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer Sold Out

This product is currently rated
This product was rated by customers from 1-5 stars. 5 is best.

5.0 (1)

Bocce's Bakery Crispies Dog Treat - PB + Blueberry

Starting at:

$9.99

$9.49 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer Sold Out

Polka Dog Bakery Wonder Nuggets Dog Treats - Peanut Butter

Starting at:
$13.50

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer Sold Out

Pork Chomps Twists Dog Treats - Peanut Butter

Starting at:

$7.99

$7.59 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer Sold Out

Pet Naturals Superfood Dog Treats - Peanut Butter Flavor

Starting at:

$10.97

$10.42 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer Sold Out

Jiminy's Cricket Cookie Original Recipe Dog Treats

Starting at:

$11.47

$10.90 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer Sold Out

Jiminy's Cricket Cookie Peanut Butter & Blueberry Recipe Dog Treats

Starting at:

$11.47

$10.90 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Sold Out

N-BONE PupperNutter Dental Chew Dog Treat

Starting at:

$7.79

$7.40 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Sold Out

The Lazy Dog Muttcracker Sweets Dog Treats - Peanut Butter Chunk

Starting at:
$6.29

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Sold Out

The Lazy Dog Happy Howlidays Pup-PIE Dog Treats

Starting at:
$8.99

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer Sold Out

Lord Jameson Celebration Bash Organic Dog Treats - Peanut Butter + Coconut

Starting at:

$13.99

$13.29 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer Sold Out

Lord Jameson Organic Dog Treats - Everyday Calm

Starting at:
$13.99

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer Sold Out

Barkworthies Collagen Beef Stick Dog Treat - Peanut Butter

Starting at:

$13.99

$13.29 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Sold Out

Caru Daily Dish Smoothies Lickable Dog Treat - Peanut Butter Flavor

Starting at:

$2.99

$2.84 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer Sold Out

CollaChews Peanut Butter & Collagen Sticks Dog Treat

Starting at:

$14.99

$14.24 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer Sold Out

Bocce's Bakery Wild 'Berry Biscotti Crunchy Biscuits Dog Treats

Starting at:

$16.50

$15.68 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Sold Out

The Lazy Dog Holiday Stocking Dog Treats - Coconut Snowballs

Starting at:
$6.49

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Sold Out

Scoochie Pet Stuffed Beef Shin Bone Dog Treat - Peanut Butter Flavor

Starting at:

$5.97

$5.67 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer Sold Out

Lord Jameson Organic Small Breed Dog Treats - Confetti Cake

Starting at:

$9.99

$9.49 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer Sold Out

ProDen PlaqueOff Dental Care Bones Dog Treats - Peanut Butter and Bacon

Starting at:

$18.99

$18.04 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer Sold Out

Bocce's Bakery Holiday Soft & Chewy Milk & Cookies Dog Treats

Starting at:
$7.99

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer Sold Out

Wonder Bark Everydays Dog Treats - PB' N Jelly Biscuits

Starting at:

$8.97

$8.52 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer Sold Out

Lord Jameson Organic Dog Treats - Pumpkin Spice Pops

Starting at:

$13.99

$13.29 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Frequent Buyer Sold Out

Chew + Heal Pumpkin and Prebiotics Crunchy Dog Treats

Starting at:

$9.99

$9.49 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!
Sold Out

Finley's Crunchy Biscuit Dog Treats - Peanut Butter & Pumpkin

Starting at:

$9.99

$9.49 With Autoship

Place your first order and get a $10 Reward to use on your next one!

×

1
2

Previous
1
2
Next

Top

Join our newsletter & fetch exclusive deals!

Submitted!

First Name

Email Address

If you have any questions, please contact us

Call Us 888-887-0063 Email Us

Back to Top

Shop for Dogs

For Puppies
Dog Food
Dog Treats
Dog Toys
Healthcare
Clothing
Dog Supplies
Freeze Dried Food
Winter Clothes
Christmas Store

shop for cats

for kittens
cat food
cat treats
cat toys
healthcare
cat supplies

customer care

mvp program
frequent buyer program
autoship program
pet insurance
contact us
shipping
returns
help
how to measure your dog
cutest pet contest

our company

about us
blog
business development
Ambassador program

Accessibility Statement

pet insurance with Baxterboo

4.9

Site & Contents BaxterBoo.com. BaxterBoo is located in the United States.
Privacy & Security
Terms of Use
Accessibility Statement