Choose Autoship and get MVP Gold for FREE! (That's a $10 Value!) Explore Autoship
Cart
0
BaxterBoo.com
Autoship Save 15% on your 1st Autoship learn more
Brands
Colors
Materials
  1. Home
  3. (470 items)
Multi-Colored
Plush
$0 - $25
Clear all

Multi-Colored

1 - 99 of 470 Items
  • Beach Dog Beach Ball Dog Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Beach Dog Beach Ball Dog Toy
    Starting at:
    $6.97
    4.5 (7)
  • Hugglekats Polka Dot Mice Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Hugglekats Polka Dot Mice Cat Toy
    Starting at:
    $24.99
  • On Sale!
    P.L.A.Y. Barking Brunch Dog Toy - Egg Benedict
    Save 40%
    P.L.A.Y. Barking Brunch Dog Toy - Egg Benedict
    Starting at:
    $4.78  $7.97
    5.0 (1)
  • Haute Diggity Dog Happy Birthday Gift Box Dog Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Haute Diggity Dog Happy Birthday Gift Box Dog Toy
    Starting at:
    $15.97
  • P.L.A.Y. Camp Corbin Collection Dog Toy - Gimme S'more
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    P.L.A.Y. Camp Corbin Collection Dog Toy - Gimme S'more
    Starting at:
    $12.97
    5.0 (1)
  • Zanies Sea Charmers Dog Toy - Pink Stingray
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Zanies Sea Charmers Dog Toy - Pink Stingray
    Starting at:
    $5.97
    4.5 (20)
  • Pet Park Blvd Cat Scratcher with Birds
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Pet Park Blvd Cat Scratcher with Birds
    Starting at:
    $11.97
    4.5 (2)
  • ZippyPaws Burrow Dog Toy - Piñata
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    ZippyPaws Burrow Dog Toy - Piñata
    Starting at:
    $16.99
  • Haute Diggity Dog Happy Birthday Bone Dog Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Haute Diggity Dog Happy Birthday Bone Dog Toy
    Starting at:
    $12.97
  • Happy Tails Doodles Quilted Belly Dog Toy - Rooster
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Happy Tails Doodles Quilted Belly Dog Toy - Rooster
    Starting at:
    $8.97
  • Snugarooz Hootie the Owl Dog Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Snugarooz Hootie the Owl Dog Toy
    Starting at:
    $13.57
  • P.L.A.Y. Hollywoof Cinema Collection Dog Toy - Poppin' Pupcorn
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    P.L.A.Y. Hollywoof Cinema Collection Dog Toy - Poppin' Pupcorn
    Starting at:
    $16.97
  • HugSmart Castle Story 2 in 1 Dog Toy - Knight
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    HugSmart Castle Story 2 in 1 Dog Toy - Knight
    Starting at:
    $8.97
  • Happy Tails Loonies Durable Dog Toy - Zany Duck
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Happy Tails Loonies Durable Dog Toy - Zany Duck
    Starting at:
    $5.97
    5.0 (3)
  • Multipet Musical Birthday Cake Plush Dog Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Multipet Musical Birthday Cake Plush Dog Toy
    Starting at:
    $10.97
    4.5 (8)
  • ZippyPaws Caterpillar Dog Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    ZippyPaws Caterpillar Dog Toy
    Starting at:
    $12.99
    4.5 (6)
  • On Sale!
    Beach Dog Fish Dog Toy
    Save 40%
    Beach Dog Fish Dog Toy
    Starting at:
    $4.78  $7.97
    5.0 (3)
  • On Sale!
    P.L.A.Y. American Classic Dog Toy - Barky Burger
    Save 40%
    P.L.A.Y. American Classic Dog Toy - Barky Burger
    Starting at:
    $6.58  $10.97
    5.0 (2)
  • P.L.A.Y. Howl-O-Ween Treat Basket Dog Toys
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    P.L.A.Y. Howl-O-Ween Treat Basket Dog Toys
    Starting at:
    $17.97
    5.0 (3)
  • ZippyPaws NomNomz Dog Toy - Taco
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    ZippyPaws NomNomz Dog Toy - Taco
    Starting at:
    $8.99
    5.0 (1)
  • P.L.A.Y. International Classic Dog Toy - Spot's Sushi
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    P.L.A.Y. International Classic Dog Toy - Spot's Sushi
    Starting at:
    $13.97
  • Mad Cat Tabby Taco Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Mad Cat Tabby Taco Cat Toy
    Starting at:
    $6.08
    5.0 (1)
  • KONG PlaySpaces Cat Burrow
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    KONG PlaySpaces Cat Burrow
    Starting at:
    $23.97
    5.0 (2)
  • Happy Tails Loonies Durable Dog Toy - Zany Rooster
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Happy Tails Loonies Durable Dog Toy - Zany Rooster
    Starting at:
    $5.97
    5.0 (5)
  • Happy Tails Loonies Durable Dog Toy - Zany Owl
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Happy Tails Loonies Durable Dog Toy - Zany Owl
    Starting at:
    $7.97
    4.5 (6)
  • Happy Tails Loonies Durable Dog Toy - Beaver
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Happy Tails Loonies Durable Dog Toy - Beaver
    Starting at:
    $5.97
    5.0 (5)
  • Clearance
    Happy Tails Loonies Durable Dog Toy - Baboon
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Happy Tails Loonies Durable Dog Toy - Baboon
    Starting at:
    $7.97
    5.0 (3)
  • fabdog® Grateful Dead Dancing Bear Dog Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    fabdog® Grateful Dead Dancing Bear Dog Toy
    Starting at:
    $11.99
    5.0 (1)
  • Pet Park Blvd Bird Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Pet Park Blvd Bird Cat Toy
    Starting at:
    $6.97
  • Pet Park Blvd Rainbow Unicorn Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Pet Park Blvd Rainbow Unicorn Cat Toy
    Starting at:
    $5.97
    5.0 (5)
  • ZippyPaws Squeakie Pattiez Dog Toy - Rainbow
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    ZippyPaws Squeakie Pattiez Dog Toy - Rainbow
    Starting at:
    $9.99
  • ZippyPaws Burrow Dog Toy - Cornucopia
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    ZippyPaws Burrow Dog Toy - Cornucopia
    Starting at:
    $18.99
  • ZippyPaws Burrow Dog Toy - Easter Egg and Friends
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    ZippyPaws Burrow Dog Toy - Easter Egg and Friends
    Starting at:
    $18.99
  • On Sale!
    Clearance
    HuggleKats Woodland Creatures Cat Toys
    Save 42%
    HuggleKats Woodland Creatures Cat Toys
    Starting at:
    $15.00  $25.99
  • Lulubelles Power Plush Dog Toy - Funfetti Cake
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Lulubelles Power Plush Dog Toy - Funfetti Cake
    Starting at:
    $12.99
  • Lulubelles Power Plush Dog Toy - Party Time Blue Bone
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Lulubelles Power Plush Dog Toy - Party Time Blue Bone
    Starting at:
    $10.99
  • Lulubelles Power Plush Dog Toy - Party Time Pink Bone
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Lulubelles Power Plush Dog Toy - Party Time Pink Bone
    Starting at:
    $10.99
  • Zanies Sweetheart Snuggle Bone Dog Toy - Blue
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Zanies Sweetheart Snuggle Bone Dog Toy - Blue
    Starting at:
    $5.97
    5.0 (2)
  • Zanies Sweetheart Snuggle Bone Dog Toy - Pink
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Zanies Sweetheart Snuggle Bone Dog Toy - Pink
    Starting at:
    $5.97
    5.0 (1)
  • Kittybelles Funfetti Cake Sweet Plush Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Kittybelles Funfetti Cake Sweet Plush Cat Toy
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • Kittybelles Taco Food Plush Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Kittybelles Taco Food Plush Cat Toy
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • P.L.A.Y. Fetching Flock Plush Dog Toy - Parrot
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    P.L.A.Y. Fetching Flock Plush Dog Toy - Parrot
    Starting at:
    $13.97
  • P.L.A.Y. Fetching Flock Plush Dog Toy - Peacock
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    P.L.A.Y. Fetching Flock Plush Dog Toy - Peacock
    Starting at:
    $15.97
  • P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Cat Toys - Wiggly Wormies 2 Toy Set
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Cat Toys - Wiggly Wormies 2 Toy Set
    Starting at:
    $9.97
  • On Sale!
    P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Cat Toys - Farm to Tabby 3 Toy Set
    Save 40%
    P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Cat Toys - Farm to Tabby 3 Toy Set
    Starting at:
    $5.98  $9.97
  • P.L.A.Y. Barking Brunch Dog Toy - Bloody Mary
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Save 20%
    P.L.A.Y. Barking Brunch Dog Toy - Bloody Mary
    Starting at:
    $7.18  $8.97
  • P.L.A.Y. Party Time Dog Toy - Balloon
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    P.L.A.Y. Party Time Dog Toy - Balloon
    Starting at:
    $8.97
  • On Sale!
    P.L.A.Y. Party Time Dog Toy - Cake
    Save 40%
    P.L.A.Y. Party Time Dog Toy - Cake
    Starting at:
    $5.38  $8.97
  • P.L.A.Y. Party Time Dog Toy - Crown
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    P.L.A.Y. Party Time Dog Toy - Crown
    Starting at:
    $8.97
  • P.L.A.Y. Party Time Dog Toy - Party Horn
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    P.L.A.Y. Party Time Dog Toy - Party Horn
    Starting at:
    $6.97
  • P.L.A.Y. Party Time Dog Toy - Party Present
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    P.L.A.Y. Party Time Dog Toy - Party Present
    Starting at:
    $9.97
  • Haute Diggity Dog Happy Birthday Party Hat Dog Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Haute Diggity Dog Happy Birthday Party Hat Dog Toy
    Starting at:
    $15.97
  • Haute Diggity Dog Chewy Vuiton Ball Dog Toy - White
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Haute Diggity Dog Chewy Vuiton Ball Dog Toy - White
    Starting at:
    $13.97
  • Happy Tails Doodles Dog Toy - Wacky Chicken
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Happy Tails Doodles Dog Toy - Wacky Chicken
    Starting at:
    $6.97
    5.0 (1)
  • Happy Tails Doodles Dog Toy - Wacky Duck
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Happy Tails Doodles Dog Toy - Wacky Duck
    Starting at:
    $6.97
  • Clearance
    Happy Tails Doodles Dog Toy - Checkered Lion
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Happy Tails Doodles Dog Toy - Checkered Lion
    Starting at:
    $6.97
  • Happy Tails Doodles Dog Toy - Checkered Monkey
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Happy Tails Doodles Dog Toy - Checkered Monkey
    Starting at:
    $6.97
  • Happy Tails Doodles Quilted Belly Dog Toy - Goose
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Happy Tails Doodles Quilted Belly Dog Toy - Goose
    Starting at:
    $8.97
    5.0 (2)
  • Happy Tails Doodles Bird Dog Toy - Blue
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Happy Tails Doodles Bird Dog Toy - Blue
    Starting at:
    $6.97
  • SnugArooz Hide & Seek Dog Toy - Rainbow
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    SnugArooz Hide & Seek Dog Toy - Rainbow
    Starting at:
    $18.57
    5.0 (1)
  • Snugarooz Mia the Llama Dog Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Snugarooz Mia the Llama Dog Toy
    Starting at:
    $14.57
  • Worthy Dog Halloween Buffalo Dog Toy - Candy Corn
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Worthy Dog Halloween Buffalo Dog Toy - Candy Corn
    Starting at:
    $19.00
  • Chomper Food Junkeez Plush Dog Toy - Snow Cone
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Save 14%
    Chomper Food Junkeez Plush Dog Toy - Snow Cone
    Starting at:
    $5.98  $6.97
  • Zanies Silly Squad Dog Toy - Lamb
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Zanies Silly Squad Dog Toy - Lamb
    Starting at:
    $4.97
    5.0 (1)
  • On Sale!
    Grriggles Rainbow Dog Toy - Pal
    Save 40%
    Grriggles Rainbow Dog Toy - Pal
    Starting at:
    $4.78  $7.97
  • goDog Silent Squeak Crazy Hair Dog Toy - Hedgehog
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    goDog Silent Squeak Crazy Hair Dog Toy - Hedgehog
    Starting at:
    $17.92
  • Snugarooz Drowsy the Dragon Dog Toy - Green
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Snugarooz Drowsy the Dragon Dog Toy - Green
    Starting at:
    $15.97
  • On Sale!
    P.L.A.Y. Canine Commute Dog Toy - Barking Bullet Train
    Save 40%
    P.L.A.Y. Canine Commute Dog Toy - Barking Bullet Train
    Starting at:
    $7.78  $12.97
  • P.L.A.Y. Canine Commute Dog Toy - Fetching Ferry
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    P.L.A.Y. Canine Commute Dog Toy - Fetching Ferry
    Starting at:
    $12.97
  • P.L.A.Y. Canine Commute Dog Toy - San Pup-cisco Cable Car
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    P.L.A.Y. Canine Commute Dog Toy - San Pup-cisco Cable Car
    Starting at:
    $13.97
    5.0 (1)
  • HugSmart Foodie Japan Dog Toy - Fuji Ice Cream
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    HugSmart Foodie Japan Dog Toy - Fuji Ice Cream
    Starting at:
    $6.97
  • HugSmart Fruity Critterz Puzzle Hunter Dog Toy - Pumpkin Fox
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    HugSmart Fruity Critterz Puzzle Hunter Dog Toy - Pumpkin Fox
    Starting at:
    $9.97
  • HugSmart Dinosaur Land Dura Guard Dog Toy - Dinosaur
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    HugSmart Dinosaur Land Dura Guard Dog Toy - Dinosaur
    Starting at:
    $9.97
  • HugSmart Paw Invasion Dura Guard Dog Toy - UFO
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    HugSmart Paw Invasion Dura Guard Dog Toy - UFO
    Starting at:
    $8.97
  • HugSmart Fruity Critterz Puzzle Hunter Dog Toy - Pineapple Sloth
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    HugSmart Fruity Critterz Puzzle Hunter Dog Toy - Pineapple Sloth
    Starting at:
    $9.97
  • Lulubelles Power Plush Dog Toy - Pawty Animal Bone
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Lulubelles Power Plush Dog Toy - Pawty Animal Bone
    Starting at:
    $10.99
  • ZippyPaws Squeakie Can Dog Toy - Fetcha
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    ZippyPaws Squeakie Can Dog Toy - Fetcha
    Starting at:
    $7.99
  • KONG Pull-A-Partz Yarnz Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    KONG Pull-A-Partz Yarnz Cat Toy
    Starting at:
    $5.97
  • KONG Pull-A-Partz Purrito Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    KONG Pull-A-Partz Purrito Cat Toy
    Starting at:
    $6.97
  • KONG Pull-A-Partz Bugz Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    KONG Pull-A-Partz Bugz Cat Toy
    Starting at:
    $13.97
  • KONG Flingaroo Caterpillar Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    KONG Flingaroo Caterpillar Cat Toy
    Starting at:
    $6.97
  • P.L.A.Y. Hollywoof Cinema Collection Dog Toy - Hoppy Hound Brew
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    P.L.A.Y. Hollywoof Cinema Collection Dog Toy - Hoppy Hound Brew
    Starting at:
    $9.97
  • On Sale!
    P.L.A.Y. Hollywoof Cinema Collection Dog Toy - 3-Dog Glasses
    Save 40%
    P.L.A.Y. Hollywoof Cinema Collection Dog Toy - 3-Dog Glasses
    Starting at:
    $6.58  $10.97
  • On Sale!
    P.L.A.Y. Hollywoof Cinema Collection Dog Toy - Momo's Movie Reel
    Save 40%
    P.L.A.Y. Hollywoof Cinema Collection Dog Toy - Momo's Movie Reel
    Starting at:
    $7.18  $11.97
  • P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Cat Toys - Hooti-ful Owls 2 Toy Set
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Cat Toys - Hooti-ful Owls 2 Toy Set
    Starting at:
    $9.97
  • Clearance
    West Paw Rowdies Custer Dog Toy - Hot Pink
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    West Paw Rowdies Custer Dog Toy - Hot Pink
    Starting at:
    $22.95
  • On Sale!
    Clearance
    West Paw Rowdies Wilson Dog Toy - Hot Pink
    Save 41%
    West Paw Rowdies Wilson Dog Toy - Hot Pink
    Starting at:
    $19.00  $31.95
  • HugSmart Food Party Puzzle Hunter Dog Toy - Orange Jam
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    HugSmart Food Party Puzzle Hunter Dog Toy - Orange Jam
    Starting at:
    $12.97
  • HugSmart Food Party Puzzle Hunter Dog Toy - Grocery Bag
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    HugSmart Food Party Puzzle Hunter Dog Toy - Grocery Bag
    Starting at:
    $13.97
  • HugSmart Puzzle Hunter Dog Toy - Happy Circus
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    HugSmart Puzzle Hunter Dog Toy - Happy Circus
    Starting at:
    $17.97
  • HugSmart Fruity Critterz Puzzle Hunter Dog Toy - Coconut Frog
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    HugSmart Fruity Critterz Puzzle Hunter Dog Toy - Coconut Frog
    Starting at:
    $9.97
  • HugSmart Fruity Critterz Puzzle Hunter Dog Toy - Peach Monkey
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    HugSmart Fruity Critterz Puzzle Hunter Dog Toy - Peach Monkey
    Starting at:
    $9.97
  • HugSmart Castle Story 2 in 1 Dog Toy - Princess
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    HugSmart Castle Story 2 in 1 Dog Toy - Princess
    Starting at:
    $8.97
  • HugSmart Feisty Veggie Fuzzy Friendz Dog Toy - Radish
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    HugSmart Feisty Veggie Fuzzy Friendz Dog Toy - Radish
    Starting at:
    $6.97
  • HugSmart Feisty Veggie Fuzzy Friendz Dog Toy - Bok Choy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    HugSmart Feisty Veggie Fuzzy Friendz Dog Toy - Bok Choy
    Starting at:
    $7.97
  • KONG Shieldz Tropics Dog Toy - Frog
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    KONG Shieldz Tropics Dog Toy - Frog
    Starting at:
    $14.97
    2.5 (2)
  • On Sale!
    Clearance
    HuggleHounds Peppermint Collection Squooshie Dog Toy - Moose
    Save 40%
    HuggleHounds Peppermint Collection Squooshie Dog Toy - Moose
    Starting at:
    $9.00  $14.99
  • FuzzYard Winky Watermelon Dog Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    FuzzYard Winky Watermelon Dog Toy
    Starting at:
    $8.99
  • FuzzYard Winky Avocado Dog Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    FuzzYard Winky Avocado Dog Toy
    Starting at:
    $8.99
 

Sign Up For Our Newsletter!

 Call Us 888-887-0063
 Email Us
Customer Service
Helpful Links
  • Facebook X Instagram Pinterest Youtube
Site & Contents © BaxterBoo.com®. BaxterBoo is located in the United States. |  Privacy & Security |  Terms of Use
Guarantee Site Secure Pharmacy Verified Website
Payment Type Logos